JOE’S STONE CRAB RESTAURANT
11 Washington Ave. / Website
A classic. Joe’s Stone Crab has been serving the best key lime pie in Miami for almost as long as they’ve been open! While you might be stuffed after a stone crab and mac and cheese-filled meal at Joe’s you must save room for dessert. This key lime pie is almost as iconic as the restaurant, served in a perfect-sized slice and topped with a dollop of whipped cream.
1575 Alton Rd. / Website
One of the newest spots in town is serving up some absolutely delicious key lime pie, and practically every other baked goods you could ask for! The Deep Dish Key Lime Pie is a menu highlight, with a delicious homemade tart and crust.
See also: Experience Florida’s Wine Country
FIREMAN DEREK’S BAKE SHOP
Multiple Locations / Website
As Miami’s beloved bakery and pie shop, Fireman Derek’s makes a mean key lime pie! The custard is made from hand-squeezed key limes and the crust is made from crushed graham crackers, creating the ultimate homemade pie. The consistency and flavor are quite perfect, mastering the balance between sweet and tart.
401 N Fort Lauderdale Beach Blvd. / Website
A Key Lime Baked Alaska sounds like an absolute dream. This unique take on the classic key lime pie is literally all you could ever want and more, made with graham cracker, blackberry and makrut lime soda.
1855 Purdy Ave. / Website
This Deep Dish Key Lime Pie is absolutely fantastic. End your meal at Icebox Cafe with dessert, or just make a dessert trip to this delicious spot. This key lime custard is topped with, of course, a considerable size of whipped cream, hitting every little sweet spot on the pie!
STILTSVILLE FISH BAR
1787 Purdy Ave. / Website
Like everything at Stilsville Fish Bar, this Coconut Key Lime Pie is literally rave-worthy. Made with a graham cracker and coconut crust, topped with local key lime tart and coconut, vanilla whip, you will be sure to cherish every last bite of this insane pie.